Start
Click to start the step by step solution
to the Einstein riddle.
Next step
The Brit lives in the red house.
(If we have used all information that a statement contains,
we do not need it anymore and strike it for clarity.)
Next step
The Swede keeps dogs as pets.
Next step
The Dane drinks tea.
Next step
The green house is on the left of the white house.
This implies that the green house cannot be number 5
and the white house not number 1.
There is still information in this statement that
we did not use. Therefore we will need it later on
and do not strike it.
Next step
The green homeowner drinks coffee.
Next step
The person who smokes Pall Mall rears birds.
Next step
The owner of the yellow house smokes Dunhill.
Next step
The man living in the center house drinks milk.
Next step
The Norwegian lives in the first house.
Next step
The man who smokes Blends lives next to the one who keeps cats.
This tells us that the Blends smoker does not keep cats.
Next step
The man who keeps the horse lives next to the man who smokes Dunhill.
So the horse owner does not smoke Dunhill.
Next step
The owner who smokes Bluemaster drinks beer.
Next step
The German smokes Prince.
Next step
The Norwegian lives next to the blue house.
Since we already know that the Norwegian lives in
house 1, the blue house should be number 2. Obviously,
the Norwegian itself does not live in the blue house.
Next step
The man who smokes Blends has a neighbor who drinks water.
So the Blends smoker does not drink water.
Next step
Now we will examine our diagram. We are going to try
whether we can fill in more +'s and -'s. An easy
way to do this is by trying to make (rectangular)
boxes. Every +
has to be an vertex of a box, while a - is an edge.
For this it is convenient to use put +'s in the
boxes claiming that Blends = Blends etc. as well.
Next step
By making a box, we see that the Pall Mall smoker
does not live in a yellow house, is not a German,
is not a Swede, and does not drink beer. We
can fill in 4 -'s
Next step
The Swede does not live in the red house and also not on
number 1. We can put in 2 -'s.
Next step
The Dunhill smoker lives in a yellow
house, does not live on number 2, does not have a horse and also no
birds. He drinks no coffee and no beer too and is
neither a Brit nor a German. We can put in 6 -'s.
Next step
The German, who smokes Prince, does not live on number 1 and
not in a red or yellow house. He does not drink
tea or beer. He has no dogs. We can fill in 5 -'s.
Next step
The man who smokes Blue Master, drinks beer and
is not a Dane, does not live in a green house and not
on number 3. We can put in 3 -'s.
Next step
The man who lives in house 3 and drinks milk
is not a Norwegian or a Dane
and not living in the green house. 3 -'s this time.
Next step
The coffee drinker lives in the green house. He
does not live on number 2, 3 or 5. He
is not a Dane or a Brit. This gives 4 -'s.
Next step
The Dane drinks tea, does not live in a red house and
not in house number 1. He also keeps no dogs.
This gives 3 -'s.
Next step
The Norwegian lives in house 1, which is not blue,
red or white. We can put in 2 -'s.
Next step
The Brit lives in a red house and not on number 2.
Only 1 - this time.
Next step
The owner of the blue house number 2 drinks no milk.
This gives 1 -.
Next step
Now we can use statement 4. The green house cannot be number
1 since it should be left of and next to the white house.
So the green house has to be number 4.
Consequently, the white house is number 5,
the yellow one number 1 and the red house number 3.
Next step
The Norwegian lives in the yellow house number 1
and hence smokes Dunhill.
Next step
Now we can see that the Norwegian drinks
no coffee, no beer, no milk and no tea. He
therefore has to drink water.
Next step
Since the Norwegian who lives in house 1,
drinks water, statement 15 tells us that
the one who lives in blue house number 2 smokes Blends.
Next step
The Brit lives in the red house number 3 and drinks milk
Next step
The Brit lives in house 3, so it smokes either Pall Mall or
Prince. But since he also lives in the red house, he smokes
either Pall Mall or Blue Master. Therefore the Brit
smokes Pall Mall.
Next step
Since the Brit smokes Pall Mall, he rears birds.
Next step
It now automatically follows that the Swede who keeps dogs
smokes
Blue Master and lives in the white house, which is number
5. Consequently he drinks beer.
Next step
The coffee drinker
smokes Prince and is a german. Hence the German lives on number 4.
Next step
The Dane lives in the blue house number 2, drinks tea and smokes Blends.
Next step
Now we will use statement 10. The owner of house 2 smokes Blends.
His neighbour on number 3 rears birds. So the owner of house 1,
which is the Norwegian, keeps cats.
Next step
Finally we will use statement 11. The man who keeps the
horse lives next to the one who smokes Dunhill, which lives
on number 1. So the Dane who lives on number 2 has a horse.
We have solved the Einstein Riddle!
Consequently, the German who lives in the green house
number 4, drinks coffee and smokes Prince, owns the Fish! We have solved
the Einstein riddle.
